Scientology Cables released by Wikileaks

Discussion in 'Media' started by anon0004, Sep 4, 2011.

  1. anon0004 Member

  2. anon0004 Member

  3. Anonymous Member

    Looks like POONS need to be sent to:
    Director of the Ministry of Justice's Office of Religious Affairs
    Mercedes Rico Carabias
  4. Anonymous Member

  5. Anonymous Member

    Good work, keep checking!!
  6. Anonymous Member

    Interesting read though:

  7. Anonymous Member

  8. Orson Member

    Oh, Russia. 2009-06-18

  9. Anonymous Member

    • Like Like x 1
  10. Anonymous Member

    Or at least it seems to, maybe I'm just being a faggot...
  11. Anonymous Member

    SUBJECT: GERMAN COURT REJECTS SCIENTOLOGY APPEAL AGAINST SURVEILLANCE DUSSELDORF 00000009 001.2 OF 002 Sensitive but Unclassified -- Not for Internet Distribution ¶1. (U) Summary: The Higher Administrative Court in Muenster rejected an appeal by the Church of Scientology (COS) of Germany February 12 to end surveillance of the Church by the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (OPC). The court found that COS maintained "ambitions against Germany's free and democratic basic order," thus justifying continued surveillance, including via intelligence means. The court did not rule as to whether COS is a religion, arguing that this issue was not relevant for the decision at hand. The decision confirmed the Federal Government's position on this matter and represents a major setback in COS Germany's long-standing legal campaign against OPC surveillance and for recognition as a church. End Summary. ¶2. (U) The Muenster Court decision is part of an ongoing legal battle that goes back to a 2003 joint suit by COS Germany and COS Berlin against the Federal Republic of Germany in connection with the surveillance of COS by the federal OPC. Since the OPC is headquartered in Cologne, courts in North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) have jurisdiction over the case. The Cologne Administrative Court rejected the initial petition of COS in November 2004, finding that the OPC monitoring was legal. COS appealed the decision to the Higher Administrative Court in Muenster, where the case had been pending for the last three years. This report is based on the observations and conversations of Duesseldorf Pol/Econ Specialist, who attended the hearing. --------------------------------------------- -------------------- Scientology Claims Discrimination and Violation of Religious Freedom --------------------------------------------- -------------------- ¶3. (U) During the February 12 five-hour court hearing, COS lawyers built their case around two main legal arguments: that COS has been the victim of government discrimination and that the government actions have violated COS' right to religious freedom pursuant to Article 4 of the German constitution. The court appeared to be unimpressed by these arguments, focusing instead on certain statements made by Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard which the court characterized as extremist and relevant for COS operations today. COS lawyers tried to play down these statements, likening them to certain passages in the Old Testament which, they argued, also had no relevance for Christian churches today. OPC legal counsel refuted this argument, however, quoting Scientology documents that they asserted demonstrates the direct relevance of Hubbard's teachings and statements to COS's current activities. --------------------------------------------- ----------------- Court says Scientology Efforts go Against Free, Democratic Order --------------------------------------------- ----------------- ¶4. (U) Michael Bertrams, the presiding judge of the five-member panel, presented the main grounds for the decision in a brief oral statement. (The full written text of the decision will not be available for several weeks.) Bertrams argued that there are concrete indications that the COS and its members are engaged in "efforts directed against (Germany's) free and democratic basic order." He asserted Scientology is striving to establish a social order in which "central constitutional principles such as human dignity and the right to equal treatment are to be repealed or restricted." In particular, he said, there is "suspicion that in a Scientological society only Scientologists could have civil rights." (NOTE: Bertrams is the most senior, and many maintain most respected, judge in NRW, as he is the longtime President of the Higher Administrative Court in Muenster and is also President of the NRW Constitutional Court, where he is Chief Justice. END NOTE.) --------------------------------------------- -------------- ------- Court does not Address Claim of Religion -- COS Announces Appeal --------------------------------------------- -------------- ------- ¶5. (U) Bertrams further asserted that given its findings and because Scientology is currently expanding its activities in Germany, the continuation of OPC surveillance of COS is "justified, including surveillance by intelligence means" (i.e. through the use of undercover agents and eavesdropping devices). He also noted that the court had intentionally left open the question of whether COS is a religious community, arguing that this issue is not relevant for its decision. Finally, the court ruled that the COS may appeal the decision only on procedural grounds and not on the merits of the case. This limited appeal would be handled by the Federal Administrative Court (FAC) in Leipzig; Scientology has announced it will do so. DUSSELDORF 00000009 002.2 OF 002 -------- Comment -------- ¶6. (SBU) The February 12 decision constitutes the highest court ruling to date in Germany on the matter of OPC surveillance of Scientology. In the past, COS Germany had partial successes at lower administrative court level in Saarlouis and Berlin in cases that involved monitoring by state-level OPCs. In its efforts to end surveillance at the national level by the Federal OPC, however, COS Germany has suffered a major setback. The German Federal Government and certain state governments will likely view this decision as a confirmation of their position on the need for continued OPC monitoring. The fact that the court did not consider the issue of whether or not COS constitutes a religion indicates that the COS lawyers' strategy of building their case primarily on this argument was unsuccessful. It remains to be seen whether COS will pursue what some observers believe may be a promising legal course of action by filing a petition with the Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe. ¶7. (U) This message was coordinated with Embassy Berlin. BOYSE
    User-supplied content reflect the views of their respective authors, and not necessarily the view of the owner and moderator(s) of this web site. Posts with embedded links will have to be approved by a moderator. Only links to external web pages which appear to contribute complementary information to specifics in the cable will be allowed. Links to external web pages should not be construed as a statement of support of the external web sites by the owner and/or moderator(s) of

    Add New Comment


    Showing 0 comments

  12. Sponge Member

    Here's a better forum display of the list of leak titles...
    (from: )

    Current list of embassy cable leaks mentioning scientology.....

    Green=Confidential, Black=Unclassified/Official use only.

    Cable date________Subject — Origin_______Updated ... ago

    2010, Jan 12
    Berlin Senate Administration Defends Decision To Deny Residence Permits To Amcit Scientologists — Embassy Berlin (Germany) 2 days
    2009, Nov 6
    French Response To The 2009 Irf Report — Embassy Paris (France) 2 days
    2009, Jun 22
    U.s.-eu Exchanges On South And Central Asia — USEU Brussels (Europe) 2 days
    2009, Mar 20
    Church Of Scientology Vs. Berlin District - The Heated Battle Continues — Embassy Berlin (Germany) 2 days
    2008, Apr 10
    Church Of Scientology Moscow Center Loses Its Lease — Embassy Moscow (Russia) 2 days
    2008, Mar 25
    Young Russia Takes Aim At Church Of Scientology — Embassy Moscow (Russia) 2 days
    2008, Feb 8
    Ambassador's Meeting With Human Rights Ombudsman Lukin — Embassy Moscow (Russia) 2 days
    2007, Apr 18
    Church Of Scientology In Russia — Embassy Moscow (Russia) 2 days
    2004, Oct 27
    Ambassador Meets Minister Of Justice To Discuss Law Enforcement And Tip Issues — Embassy Madrid (Spain) 2 days
    2004, Oct 27
    Slovak Views On Osce Meeting In Warsaw — Embassy Bratislava (Slovakia) 2 days
    2004, Jun 16
    Baden-wuerttemberg Rejects Scientologist Request For Dialogue — Consulate Frankfurt (Germany) 2 days
    2004, Apr 22
    Baden-wuerttemberg Remains Skeptical Of Scientologists, Slow To Consider Offer Of Dialogue — Consulate Frankfurt (Germany) 2 days
    2002, Mar 26
    Italian Scientologist Requests (further) Usg Help For Two Members Arrested In Egypt — Embassy Rome (Italy) 2 day

    2009, Aug 4
    Kazakhstan: For The Human Dimension Implementation Meeting, Mfa Urges Focus On "democratic Trajectory" — Embassy Astana (Kazakhstan) 2 days
    2009, Jul 27
    Osce Human Dimension Meeting Demarche — Secretary of State (United States) 2 days
    2009, Jun 24
    Kazakhstan: Embassy Input For Osce Human Dimension Implementation Meeting — Embassy Astana (Kazakhstan) 2 days
    2009, Jun 19
    Kazakhstan: Uscirf's Cosman Hears Different Views On Religious Freedom — Embassy Astana (Kazakhstan) 2 days
    2009, Jun 18
    Jehovah's Witnesses, Scientologists Under Continued Pressure — Embassy Moscow (Russia) 2 days
    2009, May 26
    Turkish Media Reaction Tuesday, May 26, 2009 — Embassy Ankara (Turkey) 2 days
    2009, May 8
    Kazakhstan: Scientologists, Jehovah's Witnesses Have Contrasting Views On Progress On Religious Freedom — Embassy Astana (Kazakhstan) 2 days
    2008, Mar 3
    Kazakhstan: Upsurge In Negative Media Coverage Of Nontraditional Religious Groups — Embassy Astana (Kazakhstan) 2 days
    2008, Feb 21
    German Court Rejects Scientology Appeal Against Surveillance — Consulate Dusseldorf (Germany) 2 days
    2007, Jan 19
    Bavaria's Next Minister-president — Consulate Munich (Germany) 2 days
    2006, Oct 4
    Bloodless Holy War: The Beckfords Vs Yad L'achim — Embassy Tel Aviv (Israel) 2 days
    2006, Mar 2
    Greek Scientologists Share Religious Freedom Problems — Embassy Athens (Greece) 2 days
    2005, Jun 13
    Justice Ministry Rejects Registration Of Church Of Scientology — Embassy Madrid (Spain) 2 days
    2003, Jul 28
    International Religious Freedom Report For Canada - 2003 (revised) — Embassy Ottawa (Canada) 2 days
    2003, May 23
    Canada - 2003 Religious Freedom Report — Embassy Ottawa (Canada) 2 days
    2002, Feb 22
    Country Reports On Human Rights Practices For 2001 - Request For Guidance — Embassy Rome (Italy) 2 days
    2007, Dec 21
    Hamburg Vs. Scientology — Consulate Hamburg (Germany) 8 months
  13. Anonymous Member

Share This Page

Customize Theme Colors


Choose a color via Color picker or click the predefined style names!

Primary Color :

Secondary Color :
Predefined Skins